EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (14...a5), delta = 0.00 EV 1111001 MAIN MATCH (15...Bf5), delta = 0.09 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (16...Bg6), delta = 0.40 EV 0011011 MAIN MATCH (17...h6), delta = 0.01 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (18...Rd8), delta = 0.40 EV 1011111 MAIN MATCH (19...b4), delta = -0.01 (weird but true...) EV 1111101 MAIN MATCH (20...Rfe8), delta = 0.07 EV 0111111 MAIN MATCH (21...Qe6), delta = 0.02 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (22...Nxd4), delta = 0.31 EV 1011111 MAIN MATCH (23...f6), delta = 0.04 EV 0000011 MAIN MATCH (24...fxe5), delta = 0.08 EV 1111110 PART MATCH (25...Qd7), delta2 = -0.01 EV 1110001 PART MATCH (26...c5), delta2 = -0.06 EV 0000000 NON-MATCH (27...Bg5), delta2 = -0.00 (TIE) EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (28...Bh4), delta = 0.10 EV 0000000 NON-MATCH (29...Rf8?!), delta2 <= -0.33 [from below, = -0.65] EV 0010111 MAIN MATCH (30...Rf7), delta = -0.04 [but +0.22 at next ply] EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (31...cxd4), delta = 0.13 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (32...Qa7), delta = 0.26 LarryC reported all-matching from next move on. EV 0000000 NON-MATCH (33...Qxd4), delta2 = -0.26 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (34...Be4), delta = 0.18 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (35...Re8), delta = 0.03 EV 0011111 MAIN MATCH (36...g5), delta = -0.03 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (37...Rxe5, forced), delta = 2.12 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (38...gxh4, fairly forced), delta = 1.04 EV 0000001 MAIN MATCH (39...Ree7), delta = 0.04 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (40...Rc7), delta = 0.20 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (41...Rf6), delta = 0.17 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (42...Rg7), delta = 0.77 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (43...Kf7), delta = 0.80 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (44...Ke7), delta = 0.77 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (45...Rgf7), delta = 0.99 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (46...Bxf5), delta = 0.52 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (47...Bd7), delta = 0.25 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (48...Kd6), delta = 1.00 edge = 3.03 EV 0001111 FULL MATCH (49...Rg7+), delta = 0.01 EV 0000000 NON-MATCH (50...Rg5), delta2 = -0.04 (from 17/34) EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (51...h5), delta = 0.37 EV 1111101 MAIN MATCH (52...Rf1), delta = 0.50 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (53...Be8), delta = 0.22 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (54...Rxg2+), delta = 0.79 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (55...Rd1), delta = 0.85 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (56...Rd3), delta = 1.62 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (57...Bg6), delta = 6.46 44 moves 27 full matches 11 main matches (i.e., at the last ply depth) 2 part matches 4 non-matches 33/44 matches at 12 ply (scaled to 13 ply from move 39 onward) 32/44 matches at 13 ply 37/44 matches at 14 ply 36/44 matches at 15 ply 35/44 matches at 16 ply 35/44 matches at 17 ply 39/44 matches at 18 ply (significant jump?0 Sorting matches and non-matches by significance: EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (57...Bg6), delta = 6.46 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (37...Rxe5, forced), delta = 2.12 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (56...Rd3), delta = 1.62 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (38...gxh4, fairly forced), delta = 1.04 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (48...Kd6), delta = 1.00 edge = 3.03 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (45...Rgf7), delta = 0.99 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (55...Rd1), delta = 0.85 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (43...Kf7), delta = 0.80 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (54...Rxg2+), delta = 0.79 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (44...Ke7), delta = 0.77 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (42...Rg7), delta = 0.77 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (46...Bxf5), delta = 0.52 EV 1111101 MAIN MATCH (52...Rf1), delta = 0.50 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (18...Rd8), delta = 0.40 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (16...Bg6), delta = 0.40 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (51...h5), delta = 0.37 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (22...Nxd4), delta = 0.31 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (32...Qa7), delta = 0.26 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (47...Bd7), delta = 0.25 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (53...Be8), delta = 0.22 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (40...Rc7), delta = 0.20 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (34...Be4), delta = 0.18 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (41...Rf6), delta = 0.17 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (31...cxd4), delta = 0.13 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (28...Bh4), delta = 0.10 EV 1111001 MAIN MATCH (15...Bf5), delta = 0.09 EV 0000011 MAIN MATCH (24...fxe5), delta = 0.08 EV 1111101 MAIN MATCH (20...Rfe8), delta = 0.07 EV 1011111 MAIN MATCH (23...f6), delta = 0.04 EV 0000001 MAIN MATCH (39...Ree7), delta = 0.04 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (35...Re8), delta = 0.03 EV 0111111 MAIN MATCH (21...Qe6), delta = 0.02 EV 0011011 MAIN MATCH (17...h6), delta = 0.01 EV 0001111 FULL MATCH (49...Rg7+), delta = 0.01 EV 1111111 FULL MATCH (14...a5), delta = 0.00 EV 0010111 MAIN MATCH (30...Rf7), delta = -0.04 [but +0.22 at next ply] EV 1011111 MAIN MATCH (19...b4), delta = -0.01 (weird but true...) EV 0011111 MAIN MATCH (36...g5), delta = -0.03 EV 1110001 PART MATCH (26...c5), delta2 = -0.06 (part since not at ply 19) EV 1111110 PART MATCH (25...Qd7), delta2 = -0.01 EV 0000000 NON-MATCH (27...Bg5), delta2 = -0.00 (TIE) EV 0000000 NON-MATCH (50...Rg5), delta2 = -0.04 (from 17/34) EV 0000000 NON-MATCH (33...Qxd4), delta2 = -0.26 EV 0000000 NON-MATCH (29...Rf8?!), delta2 <= -0.33 [from below, = -0.65] Only 3 truly clean non-matches, and a whole lot of matches with high information gain. If this isn't a smoking gun, nothing is... Even the error at move 29 may be explained by "haywire" shifts at move 28 putting the confederates offline for awhile, as explained in the main log file. And Larry Christiansen included moves 33 and 50 in his report of "25 consecutive matches by Shredder". So it is actually possible that *all the moves matched*!