Bill Rapaport's Buffalo Restaurant Guide

Alphabetical Listing of Restaurants: I

NOTE: Restaurants beginning with "Il" are indexed as if that definite article were not there (just as it would be in English; restaurants beginning with "The" are not indexed under "T"!). So, e.g., "Il Fiorentino" is indexed under "F".

[am] Ichiban Sushi Bar and Steak House
Ike and BG's
Ilio DiPaolo's
India Gate
Indian Grill
Inn on the Twenty
Irishman Pub & Eatery
Italian Village Restaurant

Key:

[—], , ,	Bill's rankings
[XXX]	recommendation from contributor whose initials are XXX
[a+]	on UB Amherst Campus (in the UB Commons)
[a]	near UB Amherst Campus (within 2 miles)
[m]	near UB Main St. Campus (within 2 miles)

(For more info on locations, see Geography)

All phone numbers are in area code 716, unless otherwise indicated.

---

[am] Ichiban Sushi Bar and Steak House.
3192 Sheridan Dr. (in Piccadilly Plaza, at N. Bailey), Amherst.
803-1605.

[SDP, 5/09] says: "This is my first time submitting a review to your site (which I use extensively to help make restaurant decisions.) [Thanks!] My wife and two kids (10 & 8) ate here for lunch this past Sunday and really enjoyed the experience and the food. We decided to check out this restaurant after seeing a newspaper advertisement claiming this to be the only all-you-can-eat, Japanese buffet restaurant in Western New York. As it turns out, this is a "buffet" restaurant where you order whatever you'd like from a menu, and it is then prepared for you. Apparently, this is a popular concept for Japanese restaurants in NYC and Toronto. I was a little concerned at first, but we quickly realized how fun this concept is. The family had a terrific time selecting our food from the menu and then having all of it brought out to us. It felt so unusual to be able to repeatedly order from a menu, knowing that our cost was fixed. We loved the shrimp dumplings and had several orders of those. The tempura shrimp, zucchini, and mushrooms were very good. The tempura onion wasn't as good as a traditional onion ring. We loved both types of noodles we ordered. We thought the hibachi steak and chicken were a little plain, but the hibachi salmon was very nice. For sushi, my son ordered a California roll, which was very good. I had a spicy tuna hand roll, which was also good. My wife had the tofu skin sushi, which she described as being similar to what she made at home. For dessert, we tried red bean ice cream, which was good, and ginger ice cream, which has a strong ginger taste to it and wasn't our favorite. Weekend lunch is $9.99 per adult (our kids' were $5.99). I believe the weekday lunch is $8.99 per adult. Dinner costs more, but the menu is more extensive as well. My family is planning several return trips, and I've recruited a few co-workers for a future lunch."

[SAS, 8/08] said: "Positive; my wife and I visited them late last night (Sunday); they graciously sat us, though it was 20 minutes to closing. The menu contains a lot of variety: seems to be more than most other local Japanese-style restaurants. The edamame appetizer was warmed and salted, as we enjoy them. And the shrimp and vegetable tempura was tasty—a very light tempura batter accompanied by a dipping sauce that was slightly on the sweet side; at that point, our sushi and special rolls began to fly onto our table: After all, it was closing time. I preferred their Ichiban House roll, but the day's special roll (with lobster and jalapeño slices) was my wife's fav. We finished off with yellowtail, octopus, and a shrimp tempura roll, all of which were delicious. No sake this time; will take care of that next time! We enjoyed our meal more than our visit to Kyoto about a month ago."

[PMRo, 7/08] said: "If you haven't visited this new restaurant on Sheridan near N. Bailey, please give it a try! We very much like the option to try either the hibachi group setting or typical restaurant seating. The place has great decor, is spacious and quiet, with soothing but not too loud music, and the service was excellent. The menu is varied and delicious—try the chef's special mango salad—yummy! Strips of mango over lettuce smothered with a wonderful mango dressing. Green tea is served in a lovely solid mug with a seemingly endless teapot providing seconds and thirds. First visit (along with the salad), I tried the tempura with soba (bowl of savory broth with noodles and vegetables), which was delicious (a bit too much food for lunch though!). Second visit, we tried the teriyaki shrimp and salmon box (respectively)—shrimp or salmon over a lovely bed of baby asparagus, green and red peppers, and yellow and green beans, with well-cooked rice (not too sticky or sweet), shu mai dumplings, pickled ginger and wasabi, and two California rolls. Excellent! Also came with salad or soup. Priced nicely at just $9. Other menu choices: baby octupus appetizer, Ichiban shrimp (deep fried w/chef's special sauce), five soup varieties including house spicy soup, shrimp, seaweed or squid salad, and a wide variety of classic or signature rolls, sushi and sashimi entrees. Among the desserts, fresh pineapple! There is a kids' menu and chef's special entrees. Also a page of lunch specials served 11:30am-2:30pm. All in all, we liked it much better than the Fuji Grill. They also are handing out a secret prize envelope to use at your next visit (but for a limited time)."

I [Bill] can't help but comment at this point that one of my colleagues ate here, thought the food was "OK", and gave me one of these envelopes, along with a note stating that his wife had an allergic reaction to the food :-|

Ike and BG's Rib House.
1646 Genesee St., Buffalo.
892-4301.

[BTe, 3/07] says: "I had the 1/2 slab of ribs with coleslaw and bread. The ribs are very good: nice grilled flavor. The sauce is very distinct and pairs up with the grilled-rib flavor suprisingly well. I just warn that mild is medium, medium is hot, and hot is very hot. The coleslaw was another major surprise. Usually I am not a big coleslaw fan, but this coleslaw is without a doubt the best I had ever eaten. Ike and BG certainly changed my mind about coleslaw. Oh, and what the previous reviewer said about Ike and BG is spot on. They are very friendly."

[RCr, 7/04] says: "We were asked by our friends if we liked good BBQ. Our response was a resounding "yes", and we were off to Ike and BG's (7/3/04). I, being a former culinary guy, was totally psyched for what was billed by my friend Mike as, "The best BBQ in the city!" Located at 1646 Genesee Street, in the heart of the city's East Side, I was unsure of what to expect as we drove up and parked. The place looked small, and I was told there was no table seating, take out only. This was cool, as we could just bring the food back to one of our houses. Anyway, we stepped out of the car, and the hardwood charcoal, pork roast, and racks of ribs just filled the air with nirvana. Ike and BG (Betty Gean) do their BBQ outside in a couple of old cast-iron smokers. Mike had called in advance to let Ike know we were coming and to expect 5 hungry appetites. We were not disappointed. I had mentioned that Ike and BG's was a take-out-only place. Ike insisted that we stay, so we grabbed an 8-foot table and some chairs, and set them up in the adjacent lot. If you haven't figured this out by now, Ike and BG are 2 of the nicest people one will ever meet. Let's get to the food. My last experience with BBQ was at Fat Bob's, and that experience was downright awful--the food and service were horrendous, but we'll leave that for another review. Based on that experience, I was a bit skeptical and thought I would have to go back to Uncle Pete's (Boston, MA) if I wanted good BBQ this side of Kansas City. We sat down outside, and BG came out with serving trays of the pork shoulder, homemade mac and cheese, and homemade cole slaw. The pork shoulder, slow smoked, had the perfect blend of Ike's secret spices and hardwood charcoal flavor. Some folks tend to use too much wood, or smoke for too long. This was not the case at Ike and BG's. The meat was as tender as can be and, forgive me for using this, melted in your mouth. The mac and cheese was classic, the right blend of cream, spices, and cheese baked until there was a slight crispness to the dish. The coleslaw was some of the finest I have ever had. Not too much dressing and hints of pickle made every bite a culinary pleasure. My wife just reminded me we had tuna salad on the menu that night as well. So much food, I forgot about the tuna. The salad had a good amount of tuna with the usual mis en place and elbow macaroni. After we ate, washed down with a couple of pops, we sat around for a few hours and enjoyed getting to know Ike and BG. Being the night before the 4th of July, we were treated to some pretty cool neighborhood fireworks. Speaking of the neighborhood, everyone that passed by Ike said hello to him by name. You see, every Christmas, Ike and BG have an open house and serve their famous BBQ for free. They like to give back to the community which has treated them well over the past decade or so. Hours of operation at Ike and BG's are as follows: Mon-Sat, 11:00 am-12:00 Midnight. They are closed on Sunday and Holidays. Pricing is outrageously reasonable, and normal portion sizes are healthy. All dinners, ranging in price from $7.50 to $10.00, include your choice of two sides. Ribs go for $12.00 a half slab and $20.00 a full slab. I couldn't get out the door that night without getting a couple of slabs for the next day's festivities. Thanks again to Mike and Laura for introducing us to this East Side treasure and, most of all, our best to Ike and BG for many more years of tasty BBQ."

Ilio DiPaolo's Restaurant and Ringside Lounge.
3785 South Park Ave. (near Exit 56 on the I-90 NYS Thruway), Blasdell.
825-3675.

Takeout available from Takeout Taxi, 631-2222.

[RDM, 10/06] says: "I'm having trouble understanding what is so great about the food here. I was disappointed with the food at a wedding reception a few years back and a previous dinner with friends. Still, we tried Ilio DiPaolo's for dinner Friday night. The atmosphere was decent, service OK, but the food just mediocre. The minestrone was good, but not better than other local restaurants'. The breaded eggplant that topped my veal was good, but the veal itself needed at least salt and pepper. It had no flavor. I felt the same way about my side of spaghetti with sauce. It was bland."

[TMcK, 9/06] says: "My wife and I have eaten at Ilio's on numerous occasions and find it to be one the best restaurants in the Buffalo area. The food is excellent, the service even better, and the setting makes for an intimate evening of dining. The staff are pleasant, friendly, and courteous. The seafood dishes are delicious and varied. It is one of the few places I have found that serve calamari in marinara sauce. The antipasto plate is large and varied. Ilio's minestrone soup is the best I've ever had."

[MM, 12/05] says: "I'm from Cleveland and ate at a wonderful Italian place in Blasdell called Ilio DiPaolo's that I noticed was not reviewed on your website. This restaurant, according to my wife, had the best minestrone soup she's ever had. A "soup buffet" was available for lunch, which resulted in her going back for more, again and again. I had the Blanco Pizza, which has mozarella, fresh tomatoes, and basil. as well as their Roma Tomatoes and Fresh Mozarella salad, with balsamic vinaigrette dressing. The food was terrific, and the service very good. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone in the Southtowns."

India Gate.
1116 Elmwood Ave. (near Forest, just north of Allentown), Buffalo.
886-4000.

Formerly called "Taste of India", and still affiliated with the (other) restaurant of that name.

[4/07] Listed as one of Buffalo's "27 Best Restaurants" by Buffalo Spree magazine.

[MJH, 11/08] says: "I have had lunch there a few times, no crowds, good service, good buffet, fresh food on serving line. But I was there on Wednesday, Nov. 12: no staff on duty; we received water and bread only, could not get any coffee or tea. When I signed for the bill, the owner demanded I leave money on the table for the bus boy."

[LCo, 9/07] said: "I have eaten at India Gate many times over the past few years, and I have always enjoyed the food, the staff, and the atmosphere. Most recently, I dined there with a group of 14 people. The waitstaff was great, with timely service for appetizers, entrees, and desserts. My favorite appetizers are the bhajia, tofu pakora, and the onion bhaji. Each of these appetizers is lightly battered with chickpea batter, deep-fried, and served with chutneys; they are crisp and not overly greasy. The chana bhatura is one of the best vegetarian options that this restaurant offers. The chana is rich and flavorful, and the bhatura, a deep-fried bread, is crispy on the outside but soft and light on the inside. Other vegetarian dishes that I have enjoyed are the chana masala and the tofu with spinach. Popular choices among those I have eaten with include the chicken tandoori and beef makhani. The spice level can be adjusted for any palate, with "mild" dishes having no heat at all. Overall, India Gate is a nice place to have a reliably delicious meal in pleasant surroundings."

[AFN, 11/06] said: "A friend and I went to India Gate for dinner on Thursday, 11/16. She had never eaten Indian food, and wanted to try it, since we recently had a Thai meal at the King and I, and she thoroughly enjoyed it. The Chicken Makhani and Chicken Muglai, which we shared, were both excellent. My friend enjoyed her meal as well...another convert to Indian cuisine (as well as Thai). The restaurant is quite large and very nicely decorated, much larger and nicer than it looks from its external storefront. The menu is nearly identical to Taste of India in Northtown Plaza, which apparently is owned by the same family."

[OB, 4/06] said: "My friends and I decided to try Indian food, and we all decided to try India Gate. Their food was pretty good. The restaurant was very presentable; the service was slow at first, but they eventually served us. I recommend trying their buffet-style lunch just in case you haven't had any Indian food; then you will be able to have different food to choose from. I recommend if anything their chicken tandoori."

[RJH, 4/06] said: "India Gate has a great atmosphere that may not be evident from its exterior. The cuisine is very authentic; feel free to eat with your hands. I ordered the chicken makhale, and I wasn't disappointed. It was very tasty, and the portion, when combined with the rice brought out on a large server, was more than a mouthful. My only complaint about the experience is the price of $11.95 for the amount I got. But, if you want quality, you get what you pay for. Overall very positive."

[LS, 12/01] said: "I had the lunch buffet twice in one week, and it was very good both times. I was happy to see a nice mix of vegetarian and non-vegetarian selections. Excellent service, nicely decorated dining area."

Here are reviews of its previous incarnation as the city branch of Taste of India:

[MEL, 10/97] said: "Real good Indian food."

[DN, 8/96] said: "I was there (at the old location next to the Sweet Tooth) recently with a couple of friends from Seattle, and they liked it a lot (I, too, prefer this location over the one in the Northtown Plaza)."

[HD, 7/95] said: "My wife and I eat there regularly and really like it. There were some problems with consistency of quality for a while, but they seem to have straightened that out. Good service; good food; and nice, casual atmosphere."

Indian Grill.
80 Main St., Lockport.
433-8899.

[JMK, 11/09] says: "Newly opened in Lockport, the Indian Grill offers a full menu and a large buffet all week. The owner took over the Metopolitan. The place is first class and looks like it belongs in NY City, not Lockport. The lunch buffet we had was nicely priced at $6.95. The food was very fresh, and there must have been about a dozen dishes. I sampled the tikka masala, tandoori chicken, and aloo mutter. It was by far the very best Indian food I have ever had. The spices were just right, and the chicken was moist and tender. The owner was there, and he greeted each table and even brought us some fresh, hot, naan bread. All the dishes at the buffet were labled and included all the specs of what was in the dish and how it was made. 8 of the 10 people in our party never had Indian food before, and they all loved it."

Inn on the Twenty.
3845 Main St. (Exit 55 (Vineland) off the QEW from Buffalo; follow the winery signs to Jordan Village), Jordan, ON, CANADA.
905-562-7313, 1-800-701-8074.

[6/08] Given 3½ (out of 4) stars by Janice Okun, Buffalo News restaurant reviewer.

[AFN] says:

[3/09] "To celebrate my birthday, my daughter took me, her aunt (my sister), and her cousin (my niece) to lunch at On the Twenty, on Friday, 3/13. No bad luck on this Friday the 13th! We all had the 3-course, fixed-price, winemaker's lunch, starting with cream of asparagus soup. Two of us had beef short ribs braised in gamay wine, with pureed squash, fingerling potatoes, crispy onions, and mustard greens. The others had sauteed trout with roasted lentils and cauliflower mash. The dessert was spice cheesecake with fresh fruit. As always at On the Twenty, everyone's food was delicious."

[4/08] "My sister and I and our daughters had lunch at On The Twenty on Saturday, 4/26. We all chose the three-course "Vintner's Lunch". To start, we had eggplant-and-fennel soup, which sounds strange but was delicious. For the entree, I had excellent coq au vin, while the others had grilled pickerel with diced potatoes in a mustard sauce, and vegetables. Their main courses were also reported to be excellent. Dessert was a light and flavorful lemon cheesecake. My niece wrote on the comments card: "Every mouthful was delicious, and the lemon cheesecake was even better than my own—which is very, very good"."

And from a related point of view, [WHN] says:

[1/08]: "Last weekend, we had lunch at On the Twenty. Their house-made breads—one sourdough, the other, brown bread—were excellent. I had the 3-course, fixed-price (C$25) lunch: winter vegetable bisque with creme fraiche, Coq au Vin, and pumpkin cheesecake. My wife also had the soup to start, then lamb ragout over papardelle pasta, but skipped dessert. The meal was delicious, and the service was excellent."

[7/07] "My wife, our visiting daughter, and I had lunch at On the Twenty on Saturday, 7/14. We all had the "Vintner's Lunch", a three-course, fixed-price meal (C$30, or C$35 with a glass of Cave Springs chardonnay, riesling, or cabernet franc). The menu changes frequently, perhaps daily, but this day the appetizer was cream of asparagus soup with creme fraiche, seared halibut filet over potato gateau, and vegetables, and raspberry cheesecake with wild blueberries. Everything was absolutely first rate. Three stars!"

[12/06] "We've had several excellent dinners and luncheons at On the Twenty since my review of May 2004. My wife has also had lunch there with our daughter on several occasions, during her visits from Phoenix. It's one of her favorite places to dine in this area. Over the holidays, my wife and I had another truly exceptional dinner at On the Twenty. We ordered two glasses of Cave Springs Reserve Chardonnay. Then we were served a delicious amuse bouche of wild mushrooms on a crispy bread or cracker. The breads served were sourdough and a walnut bread that was exceptionally good, not sweet as you might expect a nut bread to be. We then had an excellent butternut squash soup, followed by a simple green salad with a pumpkin vinaigrette dressing. Delicious. For our main courses, my wife chose beef rib eye "two ways"—roasted and a confit of beef—served with creamed spinach and "vegetable hash". I had rack of lamb—five chops, served with a chanterelle and brussels-sprout risotto that was perfect, with the fruity flavor of the chanterelles permeating the rice. Both main courses were cooked medium rare, as ordered—and were excellent. With our dinners, we had a bottle of Cave Springs Reserve Cabernet/Merlot. For dessert, we shared a roasted pear and almond tart, along with two small glasses of Riesling ice wine. It's worth mentioning that On the Twenty serves their own Cave Springs wines in several sizes—2 oz. and 5 oz. glasses—for those who want to drink less, or try more varieties. The ice wines are offered in 1 oz. and 2 oz. portions. Of course, they also offer bottles from Cave Springs and other Niagara Region wineries, as well as from California, Europe, Australia, and New Zealand. Our server told us that the restaurant now offers a tasting menu, but not during holiday periods."

[5/04] "We have had dinner here only once, but have had lunch 3 times. Every meal has been superb. Both lunch and dinner menus change with the seasons. The chef uses regional meat, game, seafood, and produce from Ontario and other provinces. Their recent Winter menu, which has probably been replaced by a Spring menu, offered a variety of game—pheasant, rabbit, venison, for example—as well as seafood, lamb, beef, and pork. There are daily menu changes as well. The focus of the wine list is on the Niagara, Ontario, region. Cave Spring Cellars has a tasting room down the street, but there's a wide variety of Niagara Region wines. The service and attention to details, like fresh flowers at each table, is also excellent. If this were the Michelin Guide, I would give it two stars."

Irishman Pub & Eatery.
5601 Main St., Williamsville.
626-2670.

[LMK, 8/09] says: "My husband and I decided to try out this pub last night around 9 P.M. We decided to eat outdoors; inside, although very traditional and cozy, smelled strongly of bleach and floor cleaner. I ordered the chicken and pretzel sandwich, smothered with Havarti cheese. The chicken was cooked superbly and was moist and very hot, although I couldn't appreciate it, since the ‘Irishman mustard’ dressing included in the sandwich was so full of horseradish (and wasn't mentioned so on the menu description; otherwise I would have asked for another dressing). The pretzel bread did not taste like a pretzel—it seemed like they just formed white bread into a pretzel. The sandwich came with the pub fries, which were excellent. My husband ordered the ‘award-winning’ shepherd pie featured on the menu. The lamb and vegetables in the dish were soft and flavorful, but the entire dish as a whole lacked seasoning. It needed salt and pepper, but none was provided. With two fountain drinks and two entrees, our bill came to about $29, excluding tip. Service was OK, but we attributed that to the time of night we came. All in all, we were unimpressed by the Irishman, but we are willing to come back during more normal dinner hours to give it another try."

[ECB, 6/09] said: "My wife and I went back to the Irishman for the fourth or fifth time last week. Our experiences have been a bit spotty, but the service and atmosphere have always been good and most of the food excellent, so we've persevered. This time around, we ordered the pub fries appetizer with their marvelous demi-glace. We had them hold the cheese, which we've found unnecessary, given the quality of the fries and sauce. We both followed with their onion soup, which we've had mixed experiences with. On two of our trips, I've found it disappointingly bland, and, this time around, my wife found it a little bitter for her liking. When it is good, it is quite good, but it has been hit or miss. For dinner, she got the pork tenderloin, and I opted for the steak with mushroom sauce. Both were served with mashed potatoes and asparagus. The main courses were good, though my steak was undercooked. I don't mind rare, so it wasn't that big a problem, but they've consistently served me rare (soft, cold, red center) when I've asked for medium rare (warm, firm, red center) every time I've ordered steak or a steak sandwich. Otherwise, it was wonderful, particularly the mushroom sauce. The asparagus was good, but the potatoes were bland. They at least needed a little sauce. We finished off with coffee and dessert. Both my peanut-butter pie and her strawberry cheesecake were excellent (but a little large)."

[PDy, 3/09] said: "Our lunch was two days after St. Patrick's Day, so perhaps the kitchen staff was worn out and supplies were low. The pub ambiance is quite authentic, but the luncheon food leaves something to be desired. In particular, it is difficult to find key ingredients in salads and soups, especially the costlier ones—seafood, cheeses, and even apples. The spinach salad was well sprinkled with nuts (which, oddly enough, might be considered an expensive ingredient), but the fontina cheese promised in the menu came in one piece about 3" x 1/2" rather than more generously distributed throughout in cubes. The kitchen must have run out of apples, with only about four l/16th-inch slices found around the generous mound of fresh spinach. The underspiced mushroom soup had minutely shredded mushrooms in a cream/white sauce that had the flavor of evaporated milk. Most restaurants would prepare such a soup with a handful of identifiable mushrooms on top, so the diner would be able to distinquish the food-processed, brown, tiny, mushroom bits from any other ground edible. The waitress with the British/Irish accent was pleasant but a little too anxious to remove plates with food still in them. (There was plenty of room on the table, so overcrowded place settings were not an issue.)"

[WHN] said:

[3/09] "Our daughter and grandson were visiting Buffalo from Phoenix for a long weekend and, since fish fries are nearly unheard of in Arizona, she wanted to have one while "home". Friends had recommended the fish and chips at The Irishman, so we went there on Friday night, 3/13. To start, several of us had seafood chowder, described as made with clams and shrimp. Unfortunately, it had hardly any visible bits of clam and only two or three tiny shrimp per bowl. Most importantly, it was bland and flavorless, It could have used salt, pepper, or other spices, not to mention more clams and shrimp. I also had to ask for crackers and bread to go with the soup. The crackers came quickly, but I had to ask for bread a second time. Our server said it was still in the oven. When it arrived, it had definitely not been baking in the oven—maybe being defrosted and reheated, because it was barely warm when it arrived. The fish and chips were OK, but nothing I would recommend."

[11/07] "Six of us went to The Irishman last night, Saturday 11/17. One couple had dined there several times, but the rest of us had not been there before. It's in the former Montana Mills bakery, which was under the same ownership until the company was sold to Krispy Kreme Doughnuts. The owner is a native of Ireland. The menu consists of numerous Irish pub-type items plus American bar food like chicken wings and nachos, albeit with an Irish twist, as well as more "upscale" dinners, including steaks, seafood, pork chops, and rack of lamb. To start, three diners chose "Irish" onion soup, just like French onion soup, but made with Guinness stout. Two members of our group had Caesar salad, which supposedly originated in Tijuana, Mexico, not Ireland but, in any case, was said to be excellent. I had a mixed green salad, with house white French dressing, which was very good. My wife and a friend had "emigrant's corned beef and cabbage" which, as the menu name implies, isn't a native Irish dish, but was "borrowed" by 19th-century Irish immigrants in NYC from their eastern European neighbors, as a substitute for Irish bacon, which we now call Canadian bacon. Served with colcannon potatoes, this dish was reported to be very good. Another friend and I had shepherd's pie, made, as it should be, with lamb. Delicious. The last two members of our party had "small plates" as mains—"lamb lollies"—small lamb chops with potato boxty for one, lobster cakes for the other. All the food was very good, as was the service. The only disappointment was the bread, which was basic, store-bought Italian...nothing special or Irish about it. Since the owner started with a successful bakery specializing in breads, you would expect better. Our friends tell us the restaurant has a very good fish fry (fish and chips) on Fridays. Janice Okun gave The Irishman 3 stars in her Gusto review a few weeks ago. We will definitely return."

[AMT, 12/08] said: "On Saturday 12/27, my partner, a friend, and I had dinner at the Irishman. Being fans of Irish food and having had a take-out version of the menu floating around the house for some time, we'd long anticipated trying this restaurant. We arrived at the appointed time and were seated quickly. The atmosphere was good, and the server was friendly and fairly efficient. Here's where our opinions begin to diverge. For appetizers, my partner and I ordered the Guinness onion soup, I ordered the seafood cakes, and our friend ordered an arugula pizza. The onion soup was lukewarm, weak, and on the bland side, requiring the addition of salt. There was too much cheese for my partner's taste, and I felt the "crouton" in the broth was very much a stale, off-tasting piece of bread. I'm not sure we were supposed to be able to taste the Guinness in the soup (we didn't), but it was not the hearty, flavorful soup we'd hoped for. The pizza appetizer was fairly uninspired: wilted arugula leaves on a very thin crust (think tortilla), drizzled with some tasty balsamic vinegar. It was supposed to have goat cheese, but, if there was any cheese at all, it was a miniscule amount. The version of the menu we have at home lists lobster cakes, yet at the restaurant they're billed as seafood cakes and according to the server contain shrimp, scallops, and crab. The seafood cakes were served with a remoulade sauce and a side of field greens with a light oil vinaigrette. These were a delight! They were perfectly fried, very tasty, and the remoulade sauce was very good. Given how good they were, I'd have been that much happier if they were all lobster! Though bread baskets were mentioned in other reviews of this restaurant, we did not receive one, so perhaps they've been eliminated. On to the entrees: My partner ordered the sirloin steak with a whiskey cream sauce with mashed potatoes and a vegetable (zucchini and yellow squash). I ordered a panko-and-almond-encrusted chicken breast with boxty potato and the vegetable, and our friend ordered the shepherd's pie. My partner ordered the steak medium, and it was served nearly raw. We sent it back, and it was returned to the table rare and missing the few slices that had been cut from it, thus now a smaller piece of meat. My partner said the steak had no seasoning whatsoever and that the whiskey cream sauce was too thick, not flavorful, and may have contained nuts (she couldn't tell). In her words, this was "an insult to a good piece of meat" and an incredible disappointment. Our friend liked his shepherd's pie well enough but felt the potatoes had been skimped on and that there could have been more meat. My partner and I both tried his dish and additionally felt that it was too soupy and not really a shepherd's pie but more of an Irish stew. Since when is shepherd's pie tomato-based with only a decorative squirt of potatoes from a pastry bag instead of a solid layer? Our friend was OK with the dish, but if either of us had ordered it we'd have been pretty disappointed. The panko/almond-crusted chicken breast was delicious. Again, fried to perfection, the crust was tasty and the chicken was tender. The potato was also nicely fried; however, I learned that I'm not a fan of boxty potato (perhaps it was the egg in them, but I also detected a hint of...nutmeg?). Bottom line: We were disappointed by the inconsistent quality and felt it was a bit overpriced for the value. However, the sauté cook should be commended, because the seafood cakes, chicken breast, and boxty potato were all very good. It's unlikely we'll return to the Irishman anytime soon, and, if we're looking for shepherd's pie or other traditional Irish fare, we'll stick with the Shannon Pub."

[LGr, 10/08] said: "This past Friday, my husband and I dined at the Irishman Pub and Eatery for the first time. After passing the restaurant for quite some time now, I was very excited to finally have the chance to eat there. The restaurant was not too busy for being a Friday night, and we were seated right away. The restaurant felt very cozy inside, and the aromas from everyone's food smelled delicious. Our waitress was very friendly and brought us our drinks and a basket of bread quickly. I have to mention the bread, since someone described it to be "store bought Italian" in a previous review. It was homemade and delicious. The first basket of bread we ate was cold, however; the second basket we were served was warm. I had the Shepherd's Pie, which tasted fantastic. The presentation, on the other hand, was horrible. It looked as if the cook squirted the mashed potatoes out of a pastry bag in the design of something you would find in a litter box. I used my fork to redistribute the potatoes and then enjoyed the meal thoroughly. My husband had the Guinness beer-batter fish-fry. It was gigantic! The fish was crispy on the outside and moist on the inside. I am not a fan of fried fish, but I would definitely order that for myself. My husband's only complaint was that the plate was too small for the portion they gave him. We finished our meal by sharing an Irish coffee, which is coffee with Jameson, brown sugar, and whipped cream. All in all, I fell in love with this restaurant. The price was a little steep for us, considering we are both students, but it was well worth it. I cannot wait for my father to visit, so we can take him there."

[NH, 6/08] said: "My husband and I decided to finally try the Irishman Pub and Eatery, and what a treat it was. Very nice decor inside, with sturdy tables and chairs. I started out with the Irish Onion Soup recommended by the waitress. It was fabulous. Not salty like most, almost with a sweet taste. Best I've ever had. My husband had the loaded fries, which were served with a bowl of gravy. Very good. The fries are fresh cut and cooked with the skins on, which always gives them a great taste. I had the steak sandwich on ciabatta bread. It was thinly sliced steak with spinach and roasted red peppers. I had provolone cheese added, which was a wonderful combo. My husband had the corned beef and cabbage served with colcannon potatoes. He said it was excellent and so much he couldn't finish it all. The place is much higher upscale than I expected; the service was excellent, the food was great, and I would go back again."

[AFN, 1/08] said: "I've been back to The Irishman Pub for lunch twice since having dinner there with my husband and friends in November. For both lunches, a friend and I had the delicious Guinness Onion Soup, then split a Reuben sandwich. The Reubens are huge, so half of one is plenty, especially after the soup. The French fries that come with the sandwich are among the best I've ever had—made from real, fresh potatoes, not the frozen, pre-packaged variety."

[KI, 12/07] said: "Recently my family and I ate at the Irishman Pub and Eatery. From start to finish, this place was fantastic. There was a total of 6 of us dining. 3 of us had the Shepherd's Pie, which was excellent. Also ordered was the chicken-breast sandwich and the Emigrants Corn Beef, a traditional Irish dish that was very tasty as well. We had the pub nachos, which were very good. The atmosphere was perfect: calm and inviting. Our waiter was absolutely the best: He was attentive and friendly. Zero complaints; this place is quality and comfort. We would go back again in a heartbeat."

[] The Italian Fisherman.
61 Lakeside Dr. (at the foot of Rt. 430, just before it makes a right turn), Bemus Point.
386-7000.

NOTE: THE SINGLE STAR IS FOR THE FOOD ONLY; PLEASE READ MY REVIEW BELOW.

[8/09] A few days after dining here and writing the glowing review below, MER, my 13-year-old son, and I returned (on Monday, 8/10) with four out-of-town guests: former neighbors of ours and their two children, ages 10 and 15. We were looking forward to another wonderful experience, but it was not to be. When you check in at the host's station, you are asked if you know about the "two menus". Well, actually, there's only one menu, and it has 4 pages, printed on newsprint (it's available in PDF from their website as 4 separate documents). The front page has the menu from which we had ordered before. The back page has a "deli on the deck" menu that has much more informal (and kid-friendly) offerings. After being seated outside on what I called the "deck" in my review below, the hostess came over to us and sternly informed us that we could not mix and match meals from the two menus: The front page with adult-friendly cuisine is only for the upper deck (where we were) and the back page with kid-friendly cuisine is only for the lower deck. Needless to say, we were disappointed by this turn of events, but decided to try to make the most of it and reviewed the "deli" menu to see if there was anything we adults might want so that the kids would be happy. (It was highly unlikely that they would find anything to their liking on the adult-friendly menu!) But just as we decided we were ready to move downstairs, the hostess informed us that in fact only a very few items from the deli menu were available in any case. They suggested that we stay upstairs (using the more expensive menu) and that the kids might like the Italian Nachos (Italian pasta chips, asiago cream cheese sauce, Italian sausage, kalamata olives, green onions, banana peppers, and six blend Italian cheeses, according to the menu). Fat chance! Then they suggested that the kids could order from the kids menu, but that was clearly marked "10 years & under", which only applied to one of the kids. We decided to leave. Now, if the restaurant had been busy (it wasn't; it was a Monday night, somewhat on the late side for dinner, with plenty of empty tables and no one waiting to get in), I might understand their need to stick to their rules. But, if I were the manager, I would have offered to bend the rules on this one occasion. As it happened, we left unhappy and went to the Village Casino down the road, where we had a perhaps less wonderful dinner, but a fully enjoyable time. I really find it quite incomprehensible that a restaurant would let 7 guests leave unhappy because of a rather silly rule about which foods can be eaten in which locations. Actually, I find it rather incomprehensible that they have such a rule in the first place.

[8/09] Deanna Scott, General Manager of the Italian Fisherman, responded to the above review as follows (her response is unedited, but I have interpolated a few comments): "Dear Bill: We appreciate your feedback and comments regarding your recent dining experience at our restaurant. It sounds like from your review, there is some confusion how our restaurant is designed in catering to our guests. We do offer two different types of dining experiences for our customers, in which our restaurant is equipped with our main level dining room and side patio for our full dinner menu,consisting of gourmet pastas, steaks, variety of seafood etc., which you are familiar with. We also have our waterfront deck level and menu that consists of gourmet burgers, salads, sandwiches’ [sic], seafood and lighter pasta dishes. It is a very family friendly menu, not just an extensive children's menu. We actually have two separate kitchens on each level, with two separate staffs, computer systems, attire and atmosphere. We have designed our menu in our newspaper format for our guests to have something to take with them. It allows them to have access to our summer events, located in the center sections, along with our menu information about our entire establishment. Your second visit to our establishment happen [sic] to be shortly after a severe storm in our area [This is correct—Bill] and for our staff's safety we chose to close our outdoor kitchen due to lightning and weather warnings. [But we were not told that that was the reason for the limited menu.] We then were only able to accommodate our guests with a limited menu on our lower level. We do apologize if you were incorrectly informed of the situation. My manager on staff did offer to allow your 14 year olds our 10 and under menu because of the innconvience [sic], I believe you refused the offer. [Not quite; it was never made clear that our 13- and 15-year-olds could order from that menu, even when we pointed out their ages to the hostess.] Our full dinner menu should have been more than accommodating for your younger guests dining with you. [Well, it wasn't; surely the customers are the ones to decide what they would like to eat, not the hostess or waiter.] We have some great meals that are even wonderful to share for the smaller appetites. We are always willing to accommodate our guests [Except for this time.] and give suggestions for what you are looking for. Our establishment is unique, in the sense, we basically have two restaurants in one. [Perhaps, but, in that case, merely asking whether customers are "familiar" with the two menus is insufficient; you should point out that there are two restaurants.] We have designed our restaurant to give more options to our summer visitors, hoping they will have time to visit both levels of dining during their time in town. Unfortunately, due to unexpected weather conditions, we were not able to offer you our waterfront deck ‘al fresco’ dining. We are sorry you had to travel down the road to experience an inadequate meal. [It wasn't exactly "inadequate". We did enjoy it, though it wasn't at the gourmet level.] The Italian Fisherman takes extreme pride in creating a unique and memorable experience for our guests. [You certainly succeeded at doing that!] We do hope you have the opportunity to come back and visit us again, where our staff can show you why we have been in business for 27 years. Again, we thank you for your comments. Please feel free to contact us anytime."

[8/09] Somehow, I had never been here before, though I had passed it many times; I guess I always thought it was just burger-fish fry-sandwich joint. It is that, but much more. MER, two friends from out of town, a friend who is a local, and I came here on a beautiful Wednesday evening without reservations. Nonetheless, we were able to get seating on their deck, with a gorgeous view of the sunset over Chautauqua Lake. Two of us began with caprese salads: $15, but enough for two people each. Two of us had a mixed green salad, which was quite nice. And the fifth person had a mini-Caesar salad. For entrees, I had their Italian Tapas Treo, which changes nightly; tonight, it consisted of an apricot-chipotle-mustard mahi mahi (tapas-sized at about 2"x3"), a filet Giuseppe (filet mignon topped with caprino cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, and mushrooms, in a lemon-butter-basil sauce, also tapas-sized), 3 coconut shrimp skewers with spicy Thai sauce (that was the third item of the "treo"), and a serving of green beans almondine, each in their own section of a plate divided into 4 equal-sized sections. The shrimp was the most successful, and were I to have chosen only one dish (with hindsight) from the three, I would have gone with them. The mahi mahi was my second favorite, and the filet was very tasty, but a bit too well done. MER had a filet mignon, ordered medium, accompanied by the green beans almondine and a mashed sweet potato. Part of the filet was medium-to-well done; the rest was medium-to-medium-rare; she ranked it below the filets at La Scala and Scallion Bistro. One guest had chicken Isabella: roasted boneless chicken breast topped with grilled shrimp, mozzarella, tomatoes, and arugula, and tossed in olive oil and balsamic glaze, with fresh lemon; she was pleased enough to take the leftovers home. She and one of the other guests who also had the filet opted for garlic mashed potatoes. Another guest had shrimp Antonio: shrimp sauteed in garlic olive oil and plum tomatoes in a "light spicy" tomato sauce over angel hair pasta; he liked it, but found it spicier than he expected. Our waiter (David) kindly offered to add more shrimp or plain tomato sauce to cut down on the spiciness, though our friend declined. I'll mention here that David was an excellent waiter. We opted to take our desserts home: A lemon layer cake, a cheesecake with strawberries, and a tiramasu. The desserts were exquisite, but huge: Each could easily have served at least two people, if not three. The bill, with wine and tip, came to around $400 for the five of us, so our dining experience was not inexpensive, though cheaper options are available. Given its location, variety, and quality of food, I'm sure we'll be back. Regularly scheduled entertainment is provided during the summer season at their floating dock; check their website for schedules.

Italian Village Restaurant.
804 Wehrle Dr. (near the Wmsville/Cheektowaga border), Williamsville.
634-1804.

Italian. Takeout available from Takeout Taxi, 631-2222.

[MER], [SLD], and I ate here [12/03]. They liked it. I found it to be acceptable, but nothing special. [MER] loved her French onion soup, declaring it the best she had ever had. Salads were iceberg lettuce; I had a not very interesting balsamic vinaigrette with mine. For my main course, I had Fish Florentine: haddock in a white-wine cream sauce with spinach and mozzarella; it was OK, but nothing to rave about. Both Carmine's and Linguine's have better food and more interesting menus.